Check three things: whether your important pages are indexed, whether Search Console shows more clicks from searches that don’t include your business name, and whether calls and form fills moved. Then ask your agency what it changed and what happened afterward. A clear answer with dates and numbers tells you a lot, even when results are slow. A report full of green arrows with no list of changes doesn’t tell you anything.
I’ve worked in SEO in-house, independently and inside big agencies, and that path is part of why I work this way now. Today I run Carson Digital as an independent SEO consultant with my AI team. I help business owners who want to keep their agency or developer, because of a contract, a long relationship or just not wanting to start over, and need someone to tell them what’s really going on. My AI team gives you specific, technical asks you can send them.
How to check whether your SEO agency is working
You can do most of this yourself, with your own logins:
- Open the Performance report in Search Console. Compare your last three months with the same three months a year ago, so seasonal swings don’t fool you.
- Use the Query filter to leave out searches that include your business name, and do the same for common misspellings. People searching your name were probably looking for you anyway, so those clicks say little about SEO work.
- Open the Page Indexing report and check that the pages you care about are indexed.
- Compare calls and form fills for the same months. Analytics and Search Console won’t match each other, and that isn’t automatically a red flag. Here’s why they count different things.
- Ask for a list of what changed on your site in those months, by page and date.
If clicks and leads are up and the agency can show what it did, the work is probably paying off. If they’re flat, the next question is why, and the agency should be able to answer it.
Signs your SEO agency isn’t working for you
- Your reports show rankings and impressions but never connect them to leads or sales.
- You can’t get a list of what was changed on your site last month.
- The agency rarely brings a new idea or tells you about a problem before you find it.
- Questions about progress get vague, overly technical or defensive answers.
- Someone promises a #1 ranking. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
None of these proves anything by itself. Together, they’re a reason to ask harder questions.
It might not be your agency
Be fair before you blame anyone. Google says positions aren’t static, small swings can happen at any time, demand for a search can fall with the season or a change in interest, and some changes take months to show. It also says there’s no guarantee that changes will make a noticeable difference, because other pages may deserve to rank ahead of yours.
Check your own side too. Recommendations waiting on your approval, or fixes your developer hasn’t made, can hold results back no matter who’s doing the SEO. And if traffic is up but leads aren’t, the problem may be the page, the offer or the follow-up rather than the search work.
So a slow quarter doesn’t prove your agency is doing nothing. The question is whether anyone can explain it.
What to ask your agency in writing
Google’s own list of questions for an SEO includes whether they’ll share all the changes they make to your site and the reasoning behind their recommendations. I’d ask these in an email, so the answers stay on record:
- What did you change on my site in the last 90 days, by page and date?
- What happened to clicks and impressions on those pages afterward?
- What’s wrong right now that isn’t fixed yet, and what’s holding it up?
- What are you working on next, and why those pages?
- Who does the work, and who checks it before it goes live?
- What results do you expect, by when, and how will you measure them?
- Do I have my own logins for Search Console and Analytics, and do I own those accounts?
A good agency can answer most of this from its own records. If the answers are vague or defensive, you could use an outside read.
What useful SEO reporting looks like
I send one report a month. It shows what I delivered, what was published, and what changed in your traffic and leads, including the problems I found. My AI team pulls and reads the data and writes the report from my process docs, and I watch the system and step in whenever something needs a person.
You don’t have to hire me to expect that. Ask for the same thing from whoever you’re paying.
What I saw working inside agencies

In my experience, many agencies are built to handle volume. Business owners are busy and don’t have time to keep up with SEO, so a client who doesn’t push back can end up with basic monitoring month after month. That’s where an independent SEO consultant can help. My AI team looks at what’s happening and sends specific recommendations to forward to your team, so you can hold them to it without firing anyone or starting over.
What if you’re doing your own SEO and it isn’t working?
Not everyone asking why their SEO isn’t working has an agency. If you’re running it yourself, here’s the order I’d check things in:
- Can Google index the page? Check the Page Indexing report. Google lists technical issues like server errors, robots.txt problems and a misplaced noindex tag among the main causes of lost traffic.
- Did it drop, or did it never rank? If it dropped, Search Console’s main chart helps. Google says that when impressions hold and clicks fall, your title and snippet may be the issue. When both fall, look at technical problems, algorithm updates, security or spam issues, and seasonality.
- Is it just you? Google suggests checking your biggest declining searches in Google Trends to see whether the drop is your site or the whole web.
- Does your page match the search? Search the term and look at what ranks. If the top results are a different kind of page than yours, more polish may not help.
- Did you give it time? Google says some changes show in a few days and others take several months. It suggests waiting a few weeks before you check Search Console again, and a flat result at that point doesn’t settle it.
I’ve also written about why you might be losing keywords and what technical SEO covers. If you’re still stuck, here’s when an SEO audit expert is worth paying for.
Do you have to fire your SEO company?
Not necessarily. Your SEO company might just not be working on what matters most for your business. Start with the questions above, and if you want a second read, an independent consultant can work alongside your team without burning bridges. If you’re comparing smaller shops, I’ve written about what a boutique SEO agency is. If you’re in St. George and weighing your options, here’s what a good local SEO consultant should be doing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my SEO agency is working?
Compare the same months year over year in Search Console for searches that don’t include your business name, check that your important pages are indexed, and look at calls and form fills for the same period. Then ask what the agency changed and what happened afterward. If it can’t tie its work to those numbers, you can’t tell whether it’s working.
Why does my SEO not work?
Start with whether Google can index your pages, then look for a drop in Search Console and check it against Google Trends, since demand for a search can fall on its own. If nothing is broken, compare your page with what ranks for that search. A different kind of page may be what the search calls for.
How long until SEO works?
I can’t give you a date, and I’d be wary of anyone who does. Google says some changes can take effect in a few days and others can take several months, and that a change may not make a noticeable difference at all. Ask your agency what it expects and why, so you have something to check against. An expected timeline isn’t a promise.
Should I fire my SEO agency?
Not on one bad month. Ask for the list of changes and the before-and-after numbers first. If the answers are clear and the work makes sense, give it a fair run. If you can’t get a straight answer, that’s a reason to get a second opinion or move on. Before you leave, make sure you own your Search Console and Analytics accounts.
Can I hire an SEO consultant if I have an agency?
Yes. I work alongside your team. You keep your agency or developer, and my AI team reviews what’s happening and sends specific recommendations they can act on. It doesn’t have to replace anyone.
TLDR
You can check most of this yourself: indexing, non-branded clicks year over year, and leads. Then ask your agency in writing what it changed and what happened afterward. A slow stretch isn’t proof of a bad agency. The question is whether anyone can explain it. If you’re doing your own SEO, start with whether Google can index the page before you change anything else.
Want a second read? Ask for my free SEO audit.

